Welcome to Neighbors Pizza
At Neighbors Pizza, located in Marion, Ohio, we celebrate the essence of community and family in every slice. This local gem is renowned for its homemade crust, crafted from a cherished family bread recipe that hearkens back to the golden days of pizzerias. Our diverse menu features specialty pizzas like Emma's Everything Pepperoni and Demari's Walking Taco Pizza, ensuring there’s a flavor for everyone. With exceptional service and an inviting atmosphere, it’s a place where friends gather and memories are made. Enjoy our hearty portions, from thin-crust to deep-dish, and savor the comfort of authentic, delicious pizza made just for you.
- 712 Richmond Ave, Marion, OH 43302 Hotline: (740) 382-6595
Welcome to Neighbors Pizza, a charming local gem nestled at 712 Richmond Ave, Marion, OH. This family-owned pizzeria prides itself on traditional recipes and a welcoming atmosphere that reminds you of classic old-school pizza shops. Whether you're craving a savory slice or a hearty salad, Neighbors Pizza is sure to satisfy your appetite with its delightful offerings.
One of the standout features of Neighbors Pizza is its dedication to quality. As noted by customers, the restaurant utilizes traditional stack pizza ovens and an old family bread recipe for their crusts, resulting in a texture that's both crispy and chewy. The menu boasts a variety of specialty pizzas that cater to diverse tastes:
- Big Cash's Meat Pizza: A meat lover's dream loaded with pepperoni, ham, sausage, bacon, and cheese.
- Lyrik's Breakfast Pizza: A creative twist featuring sausage gravy, ham, egg, cheese, and a light drizzle of syrup—perfect for morning cravings at any time of day.
- Granpa Herchel's Veggie Pizza: A veggie lover's delight topped with cheese, tomato, onion, mushrooms, and a blend of flavorful spices.
- Isaac's Hawaiian Pizza: A tropical escape with pineapple, ham, bacon, cheese, and a dash of brown sugar for balance.
For those looking to build their own masterpiece, Neighbors Pizza offers customizable options like Larry's Pizza Ring and Josh's Strombolis, ensuring everyone can enjoy a pie tailored to their preferences. Reviews rave about the sumptuous Stromboli, distinguished by its generous portions and delicious toppings combined with garlic butter and Parmesan.
The atmosphere remains friendly and inviting, with many customers highlighting the staff's warmth and attentiveness. From the moment you call in to place your takeout order to the first bite of your delectable pizza, the experience at Neighbors Pizza feels like dining with friends and family. According to Jeannette Smith, “The pizza prices are very affordable,” making it the perfect spot for a delicious meal without breaking the bank.
In a world where fast food often dominates the landscape, Neighbors Pizza stands out as a testament to quality, community, and tradition. Highly recommended by locals, this pizzeria is not just about feeding hunger; it's about creating a bond with neighbors and loved ones over a hearty slice of pizza. So next time you’re in Marion, OH, give Neighbors Pizza a try—you may just find your new favorite pizza place!

Local, familyowned pizza joint found in a strip shopping complex. It is carryout or delivery only. They use traditional stack pizza ovens. Crust is from an old family bread recipe. There is a party cut thin crust and a deep dish style ...

Now this is how you make a chicken bacon ranch pizza this is delicious thank yall

Such a great locally owned pizzeria! Try the Stromboli, they are HUGE and so good topped with that parmesan. They had us try the new pepperoni rolls, these pillows of cheesy, meaty deliciousness. Never take them off the menu please.

The pizza was pleasantly delicious. The only thing I would have asked what would be for a little more pepperonis but other than that it was spot on. And it was awesome bumping into a long time friend that was working there Jimmy the snake. Id recommend trying it if you havent

Extremely nice staff. Went in because laundromat didnt take 20s. he exchanged my cash for me and gave me a menu. We ordered shortly after for dinner. got the deep dish pizza. SOOOOO GOOD ! the toppings are nicely portioned, baked to perfection. will be returning ! ...

Wonderful experience! I was looking for a new pizza place and decided to try Neighbors Pizza. They were nice and friendly on the phone. The pizza prices are very affordable. The menu includes an array of other options. I was told a half an ...

Best pizza in town. And the employees are awesome. ...

Absolutely love this pizza shop. Highlight is the homemade crust that they make right there. Reminds you of an Old School pizza shop, which it is. Good prices, friendly staffing, and excellent food. Highly recommend!